The ‘historical and moral context of 7 October’ revisited

A new wave of books by revisionist thinkers aims to counter the propaganda surrounding Israeli-Palestinian history and set the record straight.

On 7 November 2023, a month after the Hamas attacks on Israel and with prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s reprisals hitting the Gaza Strip hard, French publisher Fayard decided to stop selling its edition of Israeli historian Ilan Pappé’s book The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine. This despite an uptick in sales. Fayard (part of the Hachette group, acquired by far-right billionaire Vincent Bolloré in June 2023) claimed its contract with the original publisher, Oneworld, had lapsed.

The true reason was more likely the book’s political stance: Pappé, an anti-Zionist, is a prominent figure among the ‘new’ or ‘revisionist’ Israeli historians who have been exploding the national narrative on the creation of the state of Israel in May 1948. Subsequently reissued by La Fabrique in 2024, Pappé’s authoritative work sets out the origins of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the refugee question and the colonial dimensions of the Zionist movement, which began advocating for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine in the late 19th century.

Pappé, citing evidence, refutes the Israeli claim that the 800,000 Palestinians (out of 1.4 million at the time) who left the country in 1948 did so willingly, to escape the first Arab-Israeli war (May 1948-July 1949). Pappé calls this a ‘pure fabrication’ mainly intended to mask Israel’s responsibility for the Palestinian Nakba (catastrophe). In reality, he writes, the mass exodus was a direct result of the ‘systematic expulsion of the Palestinians from vast areas of the country’, and of the destruction and violence perpetrated by Jewish troops after the UN vote to divide Palestine into two (unequal) states in November 1947; this was continued by the Israeli army (established in spring 1948) with the aim of ensuring the ethnic homogeneity of the state assigned to the Jewish people and expanding its territory.

Based on first-hand examination of military and political archives and politicians’ (…)

Full article: 3 229 words.

Olivier Pironet

Olivier Pironet is a journalist.

Renaud Lambert is a journalist

(1) Large farm estate. Fazenda owners are known as fazendeiros.

(2) See Jean-Jacques Sevilla, “Brazil: seeds of wealth”, Le Monde diplomatique, English language edition, December 2003.

(3) At the super-harvest of 2003-04, the price of soya was around $17 a bag, with the dollar worth 4 reals. In 2005 soya costs around $11 a bag, and a dollar buys 1.5 reals.

(4) Leaflet by the Paraná state secretariat for agriculture and supply, Curitiba, 2004.

(5) Study carried out by Sistema Cresol in 2002, cited in “Encontro estadual - Paraná - Brasil”, Jornada de Agroecologia, Curitiba, 2004.

(6) According to a report by Fiocruz/Sinitox with the World Health Organisation, cited in Jornada de Agroecologia, Curitiba, 2004.

(7) A wooded savannah region of over 2m sq km, the Cerrado covers 22% of Brazil and some of Paraguay and Bolivia. It is gradually being opened up for agribusiness farming.

(8) Speaking at the Franco-Brazilian Civil Society Forum, Paris, 12 and 13 July 2005.

(9) Created on the initiative of Venezuelan president Hugo Chávez, Telesur aims to provide an alternative to biased news from private broadcasters and from CNN. Argentina, Cuba, Uruguay and Venezuela are all shareholders.

(10) See Ignacio Ramonet, “Brazil’s soiled hero”, Le Monde diplomatique, English language edition, October 2005.

(11) He used these terms in an interview in Caros Amigos, Vila Madalena, July 2005.